Benfica’s recent performance has stirred quite a bit of chatter, especially when it comes to their star defender, Nicolas Otamendi. Following a tough 3-0 defeat at the hands of Newcastle United, the team seems to have found a convenient scapegoat in Otamendi, and that’s ruffled more than a few feathers among fans and commentators alike.
José Calado, a commentator and passionate Benfica supporter, didn’t hold back his feelings in a recent discussion shared by Glorioso 1904. The match, held at St James’ Park on Tuesday night, was a tough watch for anyone wearing the Benfica colors. Goals from Anthony Gordon and a brace from Harvey Barnes showcased Newcastle’s dominance, making the final score far more one-sided than anyone expected.
In the aftermath of this heavy loss, it seems the drama isn’t letting up. Manager José Mourinho has come under fire for his earlier comments regarding Benfica’s squad strength, just when the team needed cohesive support. But now, all eyes are on Otamendi, who chose not to participate in the post-match flash interview—a decision that didn’t sit well with many, considering he’s the captain.
For some fans and pundits, the absence of Otamendi from the cameras after such a defeat was a glaring oversight. The general sentiment is that, as captain, he should have stood up and faced the music, which is a pretty tall order after a loss like that. But Calado firmly disagrees, arguing that Otamendi is being unjustly vilified.
He expressed his thoughts candidly, saying, “I think it’s disgusting that a Benfica source confirmed this information.” He went on to clarify that Otamendi’s refusal to speak was just a result of frustration and not indicative of a lack of leadership. “Nothing can be blamed on this man,” he emphasized, defending Otamendi and suggesting that the real issue lies in the team’s overall performance rather than one player’s reaction.
Calado believes that this pattern of blaming a single player is less about accountability and more about finding someone, anyone, to pin the blame on for a dreadful showing. He lamented, “There you go, there they are again looking for a scapegoat to explain a poor, horrible performance.” It’s like a game of hot potato, where the fingers keep pointing, but the real problems remain unaddressed.
The back-and-forth isn’t just a conversation about football; it’s a reflection of the struggles that fans and players face when expectations are high and the results fall short. Benfica, a club with a storied history, is no stranger to pressure, and it seems the current cycle of blame is causing more harm than good.
As Benfica fans sift through the wreckage of this loss, they’re left hoping for a stronger united front in the future, where accountability doesn’t lead to scapegoating, and where the players can take responsibility as a team. Whether Otamendi is at the center of this particular controversy or not, one thing is clear: the road to redemption won’t be easy, and everyone involved has some soul-searching to do.
So, as we grab our coffees and start chatting about this beautiful game we love, let’s remember: it’s not just about individual players making headlines; it’s about how a team stands together in both triumph and disaster. Here’s hoping Benfica finds a way to rally and show us what they’re truly made of in the matches ahead.
About the Author
